At this point, there’s hardly necessity to recap what those allegations entail. Hindenburg Research’s Monday report titled A Shell Game with a Cannabis Business on the Side depicts everything readers need to know about the subsequent tenor of ‘research’. While the allegations initially hit like a thunderbolt, subsequent declarations by Quintessential Capital Management founder Gabriel Grego that Aphria stock is worthless, along with discrepancies in several research details, have significantly dampened credibility.
Enter Citron Research, who surprisingly appeared to support Aphria’s overall value proposition. The bearish-centric market participant tweeted-out their support this afternoon, characterizing APHA as “compelling on all metrics”, while simultaneously suggesting the “stock should see US$10.” Perhaps most pertinent to investors was the promise of “More details to come”, which implies additional backing is coming. It was an unexpected twist in the ongoing saga between Aphria and Hinderburg Research, whose communique hit the common like a sledgehammer this week.
Congrats to $CRON. A floor has been established- time to rethink all valuations. $APHA is compelling on all metrics. Cdn footprint too large to ignore. Look past the noise- stock should see US$10. More details to come.
— Citron Research (@CitronResearch) December 7, 2018
Almost instantaneously, the tweet caused algos to temporarily lift APHA around nine percent.
"Congrats to $CRON. A floor has been established- time to rethink all valuations. $APHA is compelling on all metrics. Cdn footprint too large to ignore…. stock should see US$10. More details to come." pic.twitter.com/YhkrGjR8ps
— Benjamin A. Smith (@BenjaminA_Smith) December 7, 2018
Irrespective of the initial gains—which were fleeting anyway—Citron Research’s involvement potentially gives Aphria something much greater: someone to refute Hindenburg’s allegations on their behalf. Not only that, but another peer short-seller that specializes in making its target look bad. It’s a great opportunity to let two cobras strangle each other with opposing viewpoints, while Aphria slowly disengages from the public spotlight. The old P.T. Barnum saying, “There’s no such thing as bad publicity” may apply in the entertainment world, but not public finance.
Also recall that Citron has previously disseminated three separate bearish calls on individual cannabis names (Tilray, Namaste, Cronos), making the optics of support more enticing. Whatever is coming down the pike isn’t emanating from a known cheerleader squad or paid research.
With Citron Research entering the fray, Aphria has an additional bullhorn to plead its message of innocence. Company CEO Vic Neufeld has already vowed to rebut the allegations line-by-line, which will reportedly be delivered next Wednesday. In conjunction with Andrew Left’s outfit, it should help drown out Hindenburg’s narrative of greasy insider dealings, worthless LATAM assets, and shell company malfeasance.
In light of Altria Group‘s C$2.4 billion investment in peer Cronos Group Inc., reputation among the Canadian LPs most definitely matters. Given the high-stakes of billions of dollars of multinational CPG money entering the space, Aphria will protect its reputation at all costs. Luckily, it will get additional help in this regard.
In the end, Aphria’s potential hand-off is probably the scenario everyone craves. Aphria, obviously, wants to focus on getting back to business; regulators likely want nothing to do with a scenario where fraud is unproven and collateral actors are plenty; Hindenburg already made their money, and are likely shifting attention to other victims. If Aphria can tighten governance by initiating an insider shake-up and improving best practices, perhaps everyone can go about their merry way.
While it may not stop shareholder class action lawsuits from being filed, those can take years to play out. By that time—assuming the lawsuits even have merit—Aphria’s ‘hockey stick’ revenue/profitability curve can cure many ills. In the meantime, the main order of business, I would imagine, is keeping the regulators at bay and reinforcing investor confidence to prior crisis thresholds.
Unexpectedly, Citron Research may be just the outfit to help Aphria navigate its way out of choppy waters.
Midas Letter is provided as a source of information only, and is in no way to be construed as investment advice. James West, the author and publisher of the Midas Letter, is not authorized to provide investor advice, and provides this information only to readers who are interested in knowing what he is investing in and how he reaches such decisions.
Investing in emerging public companies involves a high degree of risk and investors in such companies could lose all their money. Always consult a duly accredited investment professional in your jurisdiction prior to making any investment decision.
Midas Letter occasionally accepts fees for advertising and sponsorship from public companies featured on this site. James West and/or Midas Letter may also receive compensation from companies affiliated with companies featured on this site. James West and/or Midas Letter also invests in companies on this site and so readers should view all information on this site as biased.